The Trilogy is the most fun one can possibly have with a nerf blaster. Chunky reloads, easy to make a cardboard mag for it, shell ejection. Mwah. Perfection.

Shellstrike is really fun. Idk how trilogy works. Gjallarhorn is way to un-ergonomic, shellstrike uses shells that aren't efficient (the shell has these little holes, which isnt efficient and reduces range. You can't really 3d print better shells because they will be rough and rub on the blaster). Unless trilogy is absurdly good in some way shellstrike will always win.

All are great

I don't see how gjallarhorn is good... it's very expensive, has horrible range, and has some non-existent ergonomics.

Accidently voted the shellstrike but the Trilogy is just so satisfying

I've used the shellstrike many times as a secondary in double HP wars, really effective and fun to play with.

The trilogy feels realistic honestly, and has a fast reload time. Super fun to use as a slung secondary, but not very good as a primary.

The Gjallhorn is just too big. Fun to plink with but not suitable for nerf wars.

The sledgefire has a decently fast reload time for me. But I hate the blaster design and the reload system. It's not as fun as the other 3.

And I do play with HP, not the traditional 1 hit tag.